Kinderstart v. Google
Speaking of litigation, here's another one, albeit rather old news. The short version: Kinderstart, a web startup focused on children, decides to sue Google because its PageRank drops when Google decides to fine tune its PageRank algorithms. PageRank, btw, is what determines where your site shows up in search results when someone searches on key terms in Google. So when your PageRank drops, less people see the link to your site, less people find your site, and therefore your traffic and revenue go down.
Because of this, they sued Google for damages and also sought an injunction to require Google to reveal their proprietary PageRank algorithms (which of course Google closely guards as a trade secret.
As with the Culligan case, yes, well written decision, etc. etc., and I understand the logic and all that, but there's a little part of me that wishes that the court could have written a judgement like this:
Kinderstart, this is Google. Google is a separate business from yours. They don't owe you a living. So, in response to your claim, the answer is no. Now go away.
Tip o' the hat to the Stella Awards for mentioning this in their listserv. Highly recommended for their take on US litigation.
related: